Skip to content

Top 10 Worst Nursing Homes in New York

Top 10 of 593 nursing homes in New York, ranked using our review score, based on Medicare warnings, ratings, inspection problems, and fines. Not a legal finding — use it to prioritize which report cards to read first.

  1. 1.Campbell Hall Rehabilitation Center IncMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 67 inspection problems · $167,569 in fines
    Campbell Hall, Orange CountyMedicare abuse warningSFF Candidate
  2. 2.The Eleanor Nursing Care CenterMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 91 inspection problems · $132,957 in fines
    Hyde Park, Dutchess CountyMedicare abuse warningSFF Candidate
  3. 3.Humboldt House Rehabilitation and Nursing CenterMedicare rating: 2 out of 5 · 45 inspection problems · $270,666 in fines
    Buffalo, Erie CountyMedicare abuse warningSFF Candidate
  4. 4.Sunset Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, IncMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 27 inspection problems · $56,261 in fines
    Boonville, Oneida CountyMedicare abuse warningSFF Candidate
  5. 5.Affinity Skilled Living and Rehabilitation CenterMedicare rating: 2 out of 5 · 33 inspection problems · $82,500 in fines
    Oakdale, Suffolk CountyMedicare abuse warningSFF Candidate
  6. 6.Ontario Center for Rehabilitation and HealthcareMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 41 inspection problems · $117,878 in fines
    Canandaigua, Ontario CountyMedicare abuse warning
  7. 7.Buffalo Center For Rehabilitation And NursingMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 36 inspection problems · $139,721 in fines
    Buffalo, Erie CountyMedicare abuse warning
  8. 8.Troy Victorian Rehabilitation & Nursing Care CntrMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 69 inspection problems · $269,574 in fines
    Troy, Rensselaer CountySFF Candidate
  9. 9.Hudson Hill Center For Rehabilitation & NursingMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 53 inspection problems · $56,044 in fines
    Yonkers, Westchester CountyMedicare abuse warning
  10. 10.Bishop Rehabilitation and Nursing CenterMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 50 inspection problems · $699,602 in fines
    Syracuse, Onondaga CountySFF Candidate

What the records show for New York ranking

Homes with a CMS overall rating
10 of 10
Homes rated 1 or 2 stars
10
Homes with a CMS abuse warning
8

Medicare file dates: Aug 1, 2026. These dates are not the dates of individual inspections.

Counts describe the homes in this displayed list, not every nursing home or every care incident. A missing rating or warning is not a clean bill of health. Sources and limitations.

Local records to explore

These examples come from the list above. File dates are not inspection dates; open a report for the dated findings.

  • Not a law firm. We share CMS inspection data and connect interested families with a free case review.
  • What happens next. A case-review specialist may follow up using the contact details you provide.
  • Your choice. No obligation to hire anyone. Read the contact consent and Privacy Notice before submitting your request.

Free · no obligation

Request a free case review

Answer a few questions. If you send a request, a case-review specialist may contact you. We are not a law firm.

Who will receive my information?

Nursing Home Reporter and its intake services receive your answers. We may share them with case-review or law-firm referral partners. Sending a request does not guarantee a lawyer or create an attorney-client relationship. Read our Privacy Notice.

Step 1 of 7

What happened?

Tap the closest match to continue. You can add details later.