Skip to content

Top 10 Worst Nursing Homes in Monroe County, New York

Top 10 of 32 nursing homes in Monroe County, New York, ranked using our review score, based on Medicare warnings, ratings, inspection problems, and fines. See statewide Top 10.

  1. 1.St. John's Health Care CorporationMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 30 inspection problems
  2. 2.Crest Manor Living and Rehabilitation CenterMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 35 inspection problems
  3. 3.Waterview Heights Rehabilitation and Nursing CenteMedicare rating: Not rated · 86 inspection problems
    SFF
  4. 4.Lilac Manor Rehabilitation and Nursing CenterMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 37 inspection problems
  5. 5.Rochester Center for Rehabilitation and NursingMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 30 inspection problems
  6. 6.KirkhavenMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 30 inspection problems
  7. 7.The Pearl Nursing Center of RochesterMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 40 inspection problems
  8. 8.Blossom Health Care Center Inc.Medicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 36 inspection problems
  9. 9.Monroe Community HospitalMedicare rating: 1 out of 5 · 11 inspection problems
  10. 10.Fairport Rehabilitation and Nursing CenterMedicare rating: 2 out of 5 · 27 inspection problems

What the records show for Monroe County ranking

Homes with a CMS overall rating
9 of 10
Homes rated 1 or 2 stars
9
Homes with a CMS abuse warning
0

Medicare file dates: Aug 1, 2026. These dates are not the dates of individual inspections.

Counts describe the homes in this displayed list, not every nursing home or every care incident. A missing rating or warning is not a clean bill of health. Sources and limitations.

Local records to explore

These examples come from the list above. File dates are not inspection dates; open a report for the dated findings.

Does being on this list prove a nursing home is unsafe?

No. This list uses an editorial score built from public Medicare ratings, warnings, inspection problems, and fines. It is a starting point for reviewing records, not a finding about any individual resident’s care. Open each facility report and check the inspection dates and severity.

How we explain and rank public records · Records request guide

What to do about a care concern in Monroe County, New York

Write down the facility name, dates, what you observed, and who you contacted. Keep medical records and the dated inspection findings together. Public inspection history provides context; it does not establish what happened to an individual resident.

Call 911 for an emergency. A regulatory complaint and an optional free case review serve different purposes. Nursing Home Reporter is not a law firm.

Resource links checked October 10, 2026. Confirm current instructions on the agency’s website.

  • Not a law firm. We share CMS inspection data and connect interested families with a free case review.
  • What happens next. A case-review specialist may follow up using the contact details you provide.
  • Your choice. No obligation to hire anyone. Read the contact consent and Privacy Notice before submitting your request.

Free · no obligation

Request a free case review

Answer a few questions. If you send a request, a case-review specialist may contact you. We are not a law firm.

Who will receive my information?

Nursing Home Reporter and its intake services receive your answers. We may share them with case-review or law-firm referral partners. Sending a request does not guarantee a lawyer or create an attorney-client relationship. Read our Privacy Notice.

Step 1 of 7

What happened?

Tap the closest match to continue. You can add details later.